I was talking with a couple about training their young child when they asked this:
“Sometimes we like to give her a reward for obeying. But a book we read said we shouldn’t do that. It said kids should be expected to obey and should only be rewarded if they do something extra special – beyond what is expected. What do you think?”
Is it ok to reward our children for doing right or does that teach them to only do right when there is a reward (bribe) promised ahead of time?
Obviously there’s no direct Biblical command or instruction.
So whenever I was faced with a parenting question that wasn’t directly addressed in Scripture I would ask these two questions that would give me the answer.
- How does God treat us?
In my experience and based on Scriptural promises God rewards us for obedience even if it’s expected. Here are just three examples that come to mind:
- Malachi 3:10 – bring the tithe (expected) I will pour out a blessing (reward).
- Psalm 19:11 – In keeping the Lord’s decrees (expected) there is great reward.
- 1 Corinthians 3:14 – If what has been built survives (expected), the builder will receive a reward.
The Lord has no problem rewarding us just for doing what’s expected – obeying his commands. So, it’s a good thing to reward our children for doing what’s right, even if it’s what they should do anyway.
- How does it work in life?
One job of parenting is to prepare our kids for life. For many of us it’s expected we will report to work every day, on time and do our job. Imagine if the boss said he wasn’t going to pay you for showing up and doing your job since that’s expected. You will only get paid for going above and beyond what’s expected. My guess is we’d all have a problem with that.
So, in life we get rewarded for doing what’s expected. Again, it seems reasonable to reward our kids for doing right – even if they should do what’s right anyway.
Finally, while it’s ok to reward our kids for doing right we don’t want to begin to bribe them to do right. God does not bribe us and that is not how the real world (supposedly) works. So what’s the difference between a reward and a bribe?
Read more: Is it a reward or a bribe?
God has established authorities “to punish those who do wrong and to commend those who do right.”
1 Peter 2:14
2 Comments
I’d love to hear some examples of a reward! I feel like I’m just constantly giving praises, hugs and kisses, but maybe that’s not getting through 🙂
Our 18 month old does NOT respond to “come”, and I’d like to try the “treat/reward” style, but don’t give him sugar and stuff — which is my idea of a reward! Ha! Soooo- I’d love examples!
The example I’m going to use in my follow up blog is cold hard cash. But that is what I knew my kids – at the time of my example – were interested in. The key is to find out what motivates them. All kids are different. However, most do respond well to praise – especially if they happen to “overhear” it while you are praising them to someone else.
A thought that came to mind as I was responding was to consider what their love language is to help you in determining what is going to be the best reward. If “Love Languages” is a new concept for you here is a post that will help explain it and give you a link to a test you can take to determine yours. http://noperfectparents.com/feel-loved/
Hope that helps.
Thanks for reading and for responding. 🙂